Want something on your Thanksgiving table that looks impressive but doesn’t need its own oven slot? Or maybe you want to get people out of your way and into an activity you can enjoy later. These pie cookies have you covered!
This set includes four designs, all on circle cookies: a pumpkin pie, blueberry pie, pecan pie, and mini pie slices of each. The slices start as a regular circle cookie, cut into six pieces while the dough is still raw (before baking!), so you don’t need any extra cutters.

Icing Consistencies
Most of my sets use one consistency, my beginner “hybrid” icing. This set uses two…but I promise it’s not as intimidating as it sounds.
Hybrid icing (for the pumpkin filling): This is a 20-second consistency, meaning it takes about 20 seconds to settle after you run a spoon or knife through it. You can also lift a small amount with a spatula and see how it runs off (you want it to look like Elmer’s Glue). This gives the pumpkin filling its smooth finish.
“Stiff” icing (for everything else): I’m purposefully not calling this a detail or line icing because it doesn’t need to be a precise consistency. You simply want it to not settle into itself like the hybrid icing. You’ll still add a little water to thin it out, but you’re looking for a “soft peak.” When you lift your spatula out of the bowl, the icing peaks and softly folds over, but keeps part of its shape. This is what lets the whipped cream hold its swirl, the lattice sit up off the blueberries, and the crust look like, well, crust!
(Honestly, though, I didn’t even dilute the white icing, it was the same uber stiff consistency as when I freshly mixed it.)
To make the crust, you’ll cut your piping bag a specific way so the icing falls into that textured, crimped look. I explain and how it all in the guide and video, so don’t miss those.

Supplies
- Brown sugar cookie base
- Royal icing in one consistency: hybrid for everything – follow along with my coloring and consistency video here: https://youtu.be/gCGaPgN_lL0
- Icing colors: orange, white, golden beige (crust), blue/purple (blueberry)
- Brown sanding sugar (or white sanding sugar + brown gel or powdered food coloring)
- Tipless piping bags
- Scissors
- Toothpick or scribe tool
- Circle cookie cutter
- A knife for cutting your raw dough into slices
A note on flavor: I flavor all my icing with lime (my favorite is powdered lime), mostly because it means I can make a big batch, freeze it, and pull it out for any set at any time. But if you’re flavoring specifically for this one, orange or maple would be perfect. Maple extract is dark and will tint your icing a very light brown (which could be a time saver for making the beige icing color and I don’t think is an issue for the whipped cream).
Key Takeaways
- The pecan pie is super easy and a great confidence booster
- Practice on a paper towel before you pipe any crust or lattice on a cookie, play around on a paper towel to see how the icing falls from your specially cut piping bag
- Your stiff icing doesn’t need to be perfect (and exactly why I refer to it as “stiff”). If it holds its shape and doesn’t melt into itself, you’re good.
- Don’t spread your icing or pipe all the way to the edge of the cookie so you can leave room for your crust
Download the free guide and let’s decorate together!